Make your own free website on

Considering DORRANCE Publishing, Inc.?

Considering subsidy publishing?

Read this before you do.

Subsidy publishing essentiallly means that the author pays for the entire publishing process out of their own pocket.

In addition to the agreed upon amount of money, I am currently paying Dorrance $1,050 more to fix THEIR mistake. And the final amount has yet to be determinted.

I submitted my manuscript to Dorrance publishing in 1999. Dorrance's author representative at that time was very friendly. I paid them in full the enormous fee that I was expected to pay. When the books finally arrived in July of 2001 I was horrified. The interior artwork of my book did not match the page proofs which I had approved. They had shrunk my drawings more than 50% and rotated them 90 degrees. They placed the artwork at the very top of the page, leaving more than the entire bottom half of the page blank. This looked very unprofessional. The illustrations were designed to fit the page perfectly. They appeared properly in the page proofs. I was upset, but I was very kind in my phone call and letter of complaint. I was willing to work with them to fix it. I recommended several options that did not require reprinting the book. I thought that they could put in inserts of the correctly printed artwork or that they could reduce the price of the book and sell them as "defective." They said that they would forward my complaint to the production department and that any future reprints (assuming all the defective copies sold out) would be corrected. And so I waited. I expected the production department to contact me. They never did. At last I tried to contact them. I left messages on voicemails, emails, and letters. I never got a response until October 2001, FOUR MONTHS LATER. They apparently had not even read my original complaint. They continued to dismiss me, assuming that I would give up. At last I pressured them into giving me a straight answer, pointing out that the page proofs did not match what was printed. Their response was that it DID INDEED match in their opinion. I couldn't believe it! The pages were completely different! And yet in July they had told me that future printings would be corrected. How could they have been corrected if they did not even recognize what my complaint was? Apparently they had never even bothered to look at my original complaint in July 2001, and no one had looked at it since. I finally hired a lawyer. The agreed to pay half the cost of reprinting. Currently I am paying $1,050 more than I originally agreed to pay. I am paying this to fix THEIR mistake. Because they ignored the problem for so long there are many out there who purchased the defective copies. At this time, even after they agreed to throw away the defective copies, people are still receiving the defective books. There is still no agreement on if these people will receive free copies of the correctly printed books. The odds are that I will end up paying the total cost of replacing customerís defective books as well. The books of customers who bought something because they saw my name on it. Can you imagine my embarrassment?

My advice for those considering subsidy publishing is:

  1. Many subsidy publishers have a clause in their contracts giving the company partial rights to the characters and concepts in your work. Make sure that this is removed before you sign it.
  2. Make sure that it is clearly written in the contract that you are to see the pages EXACTLY as they are to be printed BEFORE the book is printed and that they will reprint the book if anything does not match.
  3. If you are sending any correspondence that has any possibility of having legal significance then send it certified mail so that you will have proof that it was received.
  4. Make copies of EVERYTHING.
  5. At this time I would definitely NOT recommend Dorrance to anyone. I will definiely never use them again. There are many other subsidy publishing companies out there if that is the way that you want to go.
  6. Back to the Matt-Page

    Considering DORRANCE publishing?Considering subsidy publishing? Read this before you do.
    Created by Matthew Barron
    Updated 11/16/01
    Send an E-mail to Matthew Barron